Monday, March 15, 2010

In which the irregular update schedule continues

Over the past couple of weeks, for whatever reason, I decided that I'd like to watch The Big Sleep and Murder, My Sweet again. I've seen them both multiple times, and, to be honest, I like them both. I've also read both books. I'm a big fan of Raymond Chandler's writing and was slightly disappointed when I realized I'd read all of his books.

The reason I bring any of this up is because I found something kind of weird. Not about the movies themselves, but my reaction to them.


I really like The Big Sleep. I think it might be one of Chandler's best (along with The Long Goodbye), and while Farewell, My Lovely is good (very good), it's not as good as The Big Sleep.


On the other hand, while I think The Big Sleep is a good movie, I think Murder, My Sweet is better. I like Dick Powell as Philip Marlowe more than I do Humphry Bogart. And while Bogart and Lauren Bacall have great chemistry together in The Big Sleep, the movie too often feels like the Bogey-Bacall show and not about a murder at all. And, while Bogart gives a good performance, I can't help but enjoy Powell's portrayal a bit more.

While The Big Sleep may be my favorite of Raymond Chandler's books, Murder, My Sweet may well be my favorite Chandler adaptation.

Comments (2)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Hmm, I haven't seen Murder, My Sweet but I'm interested to see if your assessment is correct. I've only seen the Bogart and Gould portrayals of Philip Marlowe, and while the latter is incredibly funny and likable in The Long Goodbye, I can't imagine anyone topping good ol' Humphrey.
1 reply · active 784 weeks ago
Part of the problem is that I don't really like Bogart as Marlowe. I think he was perfect as Sam Spade, though. Bogart was as perfect for that role as William Powell was for the role of Nick Charles in The Thin Man. And that may be the problem. His portrayal of Spade overshadows his Marlowe. I'm not sure that any of the actors who played Marlowe were perfect for the role, but Dick Powell is my favorite.

Post a new comment

Comments by